Bitcoin Mining: The Free Lottery

by Jon on June 3, 2011

There is a shadow economy that is growing online: bitcoins, an anonymous peer-to-peer currency that was created by Satoshi Nakamoto (a presumed pseudonym; his/her actual identity is not known). Commercial digital currencies have been tried in the past (Facebook Credits being the largest recent example) but the thing that makes bitcoins different is that–like p2p networks such as Bitorrent, it is decentralized–meaning that it is largely out of the control of regulators, corporations and litigation.  Already, there are exchanges available for trading between bitcoins and real currency (as well as a way to exchange Bitcoin for Linden Dollars), which gives them actual value. Nobody knows whether the value will hold up, or whether bitcoins amount to a large ponzi scheme–I suspect that the value could collapse as easily as it has run up recently.  But the idea of bitcoins is certainly fascinating, despite the ability to use them to trade in illicit goods as readily as they may be used to circumvent government oppression in certain parts of the world.

The pool of available bitcoins is growing over time, thanks to an inflation algorithm that is built-in to the protocol. New bitcoins can be created by “mining,” which is essentially running an algorithm akin to Folding@Home–except you’re solving for an algorithm that rewards bitcoins.  Before you get too excited: it takes enormous computing power to extract a significant amount of bitcoin currency. Some people have actually set up mining operations on specially-optimized computing hardware, but it’s questionable whether the amount of bitcoin they’re extracting is greater than the cost of power consumption (although it raises an interesting possibility for people who have access to a renewable power source, like a private wind turbine!)

You can run a bitcoin client on your computer, and it’ll happily churn through the algorithm day in and day out, but will probably take hundreds of days for you to strike a bitcoin payout.  Of course, it could be faster: it’s ultimately a function of luck, and you could get a payout on the first day.

It’s sort of a legalized lottery, where you “buy in” with energy and CPU power, and get paid back in the form of bitcoins.

It’s a fascinating and somewhat bizarre form of currency creation that parallels things like the gold farming that has emerged in MMORPG games.  And of course, the “luck” aspect of creating bitcoins is also a type of game.  You install the bitcoin software yourself (which includes the ability to mine using your computer’s spare cycles), or you could use Web-based software that allows you to mine as part of a pool (and split the payout with other people).  You too could soon be earning pennies per week from home! (As an experiment, I’ve attached a script to my website to generate some Bitcoins using the spare cycles you have available while visiting this website, using the code available from bitcoinplus.com).

Thank you for reading this article. Please follow me on Twitter to hear more from me on innovation, games and entrepreneurship. If you'd like to learn how games can transform your business, also check out my book, Game On: Energize Your Business with Social Media Games.

{ 3 trackbacks }

Hello World! | Students for Free Culture - Europe
June 3, 2011 at 10:50 pm
FT Alphaville » Virtual money, from real central bank mistrust
June 6, 2011 at 7:31 am
Anyone here run bitcoin mining? - Realm of Excursion
July 7, 2011 at 9:25 am

{ 7 comments… read them below or add one }

Jeremy SpringfieldNo Gravatar June 3, 2011 at 9:32 am

All Things Considered on NPR recently mentioned bitcoins. I was a bit frustrated with the lack of information in the post. There wasn’t much more than basic econ 101 information. “This is a bitcoin, its money”. So I appreciated you looking into the issue with greater depth.

http://www.npr.org/2011/05/24/136620231/what-are-bitcoins

Peer to Peer money sounds a bit like the Sci Fi future presented in the Shadowrun/Cyberpunk/SnowCrash future of the late 1980’s early 1990’s. The ‘Credits’/'credstick’ idea.

Assuming the algorithm stays the same, there will be a convergence of processing power and bitcoin inflation. At some point processors in cell phones will be powerful enough to be able to mine bitcoins extremely quickly (super computer cell phones being a long way in the future, but still). Do they plan to update the algorithm to keep pace with the advance of processing speed? Another way of getting at my thought is that it sounds like the natural inflation of the system has some ‘future proof’ issues.

JonNo Gravatar June 3, 2011 at 9:44 am

@Jeremy

Thanks for your comments. Approximately every two weeks, the bitcoin algorithm increases the difficulty of the puzzle being solved, which allows it to account for the growth in processing power as well as the number of people who are “mining.” Meanwhile, the percentage of the supply will decrease over time (by 2013, about half of the bitcoins which will ever be supplied will have been created; but 2017 about 3/4, and then continuing to taper off).

Alex WinterNo Gravatar June 6, 2011 at 9:47 am

Not sure why exactly I would be rewarded with bitcoins by “mining” or solving an algorithm that rewards the solver with bitcoins? Seems circular to me. I thought the algorithm would be harnessing CPU power for other purposes – distributed computing across a cloud network or applying CPU power to something like SETI@home. I’m trying it out and I see the potential value of bitcoins but I don’t understand the purpose of using CPU power to “solve” a bitcoin algorithm. Who benefits from my CPU / GPU processing power?

apoNo Gravatar June 6, 2011 at 10:12 am

In my eyes that’s quite a bizarre snowball system. But maybe I did not fully understand. It seems that the first bitcoin gamble sites are starting to grow. E.g. There’s a bitcoin cointoss site among many others. http://bit.ly/jLDsXe

JonNo Gravatar June 6, 2011 at 12:20 pm

@Alex You aren’t going to solve anything that is as noble as SETI@home or Folding@Home by doing Bitcoin mining. The only benefit it for the bitcoin economy (and you’re also participating in verifying transactions, since it is a distributed network). It does raise an interesting question, though: what would it take to create a fluid economy for CPU power? Maybe something could be set up where bidders would be willing pay with bitcoin to get you to make your spare CPU available for things like SET, Folding, etc.

earlNo Gravatar June 6, 2011 at 2:48 pm

Bitcoin miners do the processing that verifies the transactions in the peer two peer network. The reward is not the only reason to do that.

Adrian PeirsonNo Gravatar June 11, 2011 at 5:45 pm

The possibility of finding blocks of coins grows less and less, people are already forming mining pools, to share CPU resources, but it seems to me, pretty soon, only very large coroporations will have the computing power to solve the cryptic puzzles needed to release the coins.
Wouldn’t surprise me then in an effort to gain control over this decentralized currency, Big Govt was doing a little mining of its own.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: