Our Evolving Minds: Stravinsky and Nine Inch Nails

by Jon on May 28, 2010

Our minds can change over time–because our brains are literally being rewired throughout our lives.  Time, space, external media and internal memory are interconnected through our neural circuitry.  Understanding this is important for anyone who deals with art, media, technology or society.

To explain this, I’d like you travel with me to 1907.  This is the year that Proust published Swann’s Way, the first volume of In Search of Lost Time, where he struggles with the relationship of time, space and the mind, including his revolutionary ideas about involuntary memory. Sometimes, it is like reading science-fiction (written before there was much science-fiction), such as when he describes a church as “an edifice occupying, so to speak, a four-dimensional space–the name of the fourth being Time–”

The surprising thing here is that Einstein had only just made his first publication about relativity in 1905; and Herman Minkowski didn’t integrate the concept of space-time mathematically until 1908–a year after Swann’s Way went to press.   This got me thinking: how often do artists intuitively arrive at an idea that is later born-out by the scientific method?

It turns out that I’m not the only one.  Jonah Lerher, a neuroscientist and author (who also worked in some world-class restaurants) wrote Proust was a Neuroscientist, a book that shows how the artistic process can sometimes prefigure scientific theory. More recently, he released another book called How We Decide, which deals with the strange and surprising ways that we make decision.  I just had the pleasure of finishing them both back-to-back.

One of the more interesting insights from Proust was an explanation of how we develop certain musical tastes.  I’d often wondered why music taste tends to shift between generations; my parents couldn’t stand what I listened to–a phenomena most people have experienced.  Is it simply a matter of the generation gap, or is there a biological basis for it?

A personal experience with music: since the mid-90’s, I had made several attempts to listen to Trent Reznor’s Nine Inch Mails–with little success.  It sounded like chaos to me.  At the same time, my friends kept telling me how great it was.  Eventually, I found a song that I really liked (Hurt, a “cross-over” hit), and that acted as the gateway to a lot of his other music.  Slowly, even the stuff that previously sounded like noise started to sound really good.  Now I consider myself a fan.



Why is this?  Jonah Lehrer explains how music has the power to rewire our brains.  When something is unfamiliar, it sounds like noise.  In the early twentieth century, Igor Stravinsky caused a riot with Rites of Spring, a symphony so full of dissonance that the audience went berserk and he was literally chased out of the opera house.  People weren’t ready for him yet.  Three decades later, Rites of Spring was one of the pieces chosen for Disney’s Fantasia.   What had once been a cause of pandemonium was now popular entertainment.



I’m left wondering how much this rewiring process is going on across culture all the time.  There’s a time and place for any type of media; but sometimes people’s brains literally aren’t ready for it.  If you are interested in how the mind works, then I recommend both of Lehrer’s books.

Thank you for reading this article. Please follow me on Twitter to hear more from me on innovation, games and entrepreneurship. If you'd like to learn how games can transform your business, also check out my book, Game On: Energize Your Business with Social Media Games.

{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }

Alexander SorokinNo Gravatar May 28, 2010 at 11:30 pm

It isn’t fair to pick an author, who outlined something that was later developed into a scientific idea or technology. We have the power of hindsight and the luxury to ignore the others, the ones whose predictions never materialized.

It is true that our life is built upon constant appreciation of the world through our past experience. Our knowledge derives from objective facts, from the thinking we pick up in school, from the behaviours of other people we observe. The music is no different. It is crafted to introduce a theme and then develop it. If we miss the introduction, we are lost. Not forever, no. We can find a bridge, pick up that theme some place else and then suddenly realize the music is there.

Matt FairchildNo Gravatar June 21, 2010 at 3:40 pm

Great post on a great subject. It’s pretty fascinating to see trends emerge in both art and science at roughly the same time. For instance, I once attended a lecture where the speaker marveled at how Cubism (with Picasso’s Women D’Avignon) and Relativity both took hold at the same time, both of them revolutionary in their use of multiple perspectives. He went on to compare the evolution of how we conceptualize the atom with the writings of Gertrude Stein.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: